The G.M.O. debate

gmo-genetically-modified-organism_50290d5e92a11_w1500An article in the New York Times Sunday Review section from October 25, troubled me this morning, an opinion piece by Mark Lynas titled “Europe Turns Against Science.”

The context is the continuing argument over genetically modified seeds, or GMOs. European countries “announced bans on the cultivation of genetically modified crops.”

I’ve watched this argument, GMOs vs. non-GMO foods, and cannot find a reasonable answer. My nephew, an organic farmer, is vocally opposed to GMOs. I understand and appreciate his position. Here at our house, we buy organic produce and organic chicken and good quality meats. We rarely go out to dinner, but we eat well.

My problem with the furor is two-fold. 1. It reminds me of the furor over immunizations for children and the ensuing measles and whooping cough outbreaks; and 2. my dad was planting GMOs back in the 1950s with NC+ seeds. In other words, GMOs have been in our food chain for sixty years.

Which is not to say there isn’t a problem. But the problems are wide spread and complicated in our complicated world.

From the article: One study found that G.M.O. cultivation has led to a 40 percent reduction in insecticide spraying worldwide.

That’s huge. Insecticide use produced ecological problems throughout the world. Think honey bees and their decline. Weed spraying is also reduced by GMO use. Think monarch butterflies and the milkweed pods they need. Although the reduction of milkweed also has to do with the increase in corporate farming. Drive along most country roads and you’ll see what I mean. Uncultivated fence rows rarely exist anymore. As I said, most answers to problems are complicated.

Following Europe’s lead, no country in sub-Sahara Africa, except for South Africa, permits GMO. cultivation. Lynas writes, “Yet from drought-tolerant maize to virus-resistant cassava, many biotech traits are being developed that could quickly improve the livelihoods of poorer African farmers.”

He goes on to write of visiting malnourished children in Tanzania whose families were hungry because the cassava “were wiped out by brown-streak disease.” Modified cassava has resistance to that virus.

But here’s the line that got to me: because of the ban, “we are witnessing a historic injustice perpetrated by the well fed on the food insecure.”

My family is well-fed. I’d rather not make those who are “food insecure” less secure.

I understand the argument against Monsanto’s wide-reaching dominance, but the argument against G.M.O.s leads me to remember the 1950s yellow NC+ sign, proudly guarding our country farm’s lane.

Our farm family never had much money, but we always had food.

.

 

 

 

 

6 thoughts on “The G.M.O. debate

  1. Janet, you’ve touched on some of the issues succinctly. I do think that foods with GMO’s should be labeled so that people can make informed decisions. GMO foods have made huge differences in many places. It’s hard to know what’s really true, unfortunately. It’s hard to tell people who are starving that we won’t let them have food they need to live because “it’s bad for them.” Really? Starving is worse. On the other hand, I, who am not against big business on principle, detest Monsanto with all my soul. Any company that sues people whose heirloom crops have been tainted by their GMO’s (among other evils) is not on my favorite list. The fact that anyone sides with them legally is egregious.

    janet

    1. It is hard to know what’s true, I agree. From what I’ve read of Monsanto’s suits, they sue farmers who reuse seeds first provided by Monsanto. I don’t know if that’s the “whole truth” which we agree is hard to pin down, but that’s what I’ve read. Which is not to defend the monopoly three seed companies have on the market.

      Like you, I believe starving is worse. I just don’t know how dangerous modified seeds are, and I also know buying organic isn’t in many people’s budgets. It’s hard to form definitive opinions when facts are so muddy, as most facts are these days!

      Thanks so much for commenting.

I love conversations! Let's start one.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s