Dancing on the Head of a Pin

Like fear, hope is always about something that might happen in the future. It is never about what is right here and now… hope can remove us from the present and leave us hanging somewhere between what is and what might be…There is a difference, I found, in taking refuge in the hope that present circumstances can be changed and in allowing hope to keep you from knowing that this is one of those things you cannot change.  Kathy Torpie, in her book, Losing Face.

Kathy’s words have remained with me. I look at them from time to time and think about how I am using hope: whether I am acting in an unrealistic way. Kathy’s thought is similar to theologian Reinhold Niebuhr’s prayer, commonly called The Serenity Prayer:  “God, grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change; courage to change the things I can; and wisdom to know the difference.” But there’s an added depth to Kathy’s in “…allowing hope to keep you from knowing…”

For some unknown reason, thinking about hope led me to remembering another oft-repeated phrase, “How many angels can dance on the head of a pin?” Attributed to Aquinas and medieval convoluted arguments, it points to an unknowable quality. In other words, I’m wondering if the ability to know what one can change and what one must accept is unknowable in concept and only knowable in experience.

The experience of knowing what I can change and what I can’t has often been a slow process for me. I can’t even begin to count the times I have, metaphorically, stood in front of an unmovable wall and banged my head against it until my head hurt and I had to stop. Many times, after a rest, I’d return to banging my head as if I could somehow, with the force of my will, made a difference.

Reminds me of the old joke: Doctor, it hurts when I push right here…Well, don’t push there.

But I also know it has taken practice to learn when more effort is required and when effort is futile. When is “surrender” like “giving up” and when is it “letting go?” Where is the balance point? That place of dancing but not forcing? 

I suspect the answer is more in the doing than in the theorizing, more in the personal than in the general. At least, it is for me. I can read and learn and theorize and ponder, but I can only find my balance point in doing and in attention to experience.

It also seems to me that the only way we can find that-which-we-call-Holy is through experience. Peace is an experience; trust – or lack of trust – comes from experience; pain – or healing – comes from experience.

Life – and learning – is such a patchwork quilt! I also know that my primary way of learning is kinesthetic; others have vision or hearing as primary ways of learning. But aren’t those experiences, too? In other words, “The Voice” as I call it, the words that come to teach and guide me, have been words I’ve heard in my head. Auditory from within. Does that mean auditory learning in the same way as learning from auditory sounds that come from without? Does “seeing” and learning from dreams and visions mean the same as visual learning?

I may tangle myself here as tightly as the medieval philosophers managed to do.

But if everything we learn and know happens in the mind, and no one has yet discovered where the “mind” resides, aren’t we all creating it for ourselves as we go along?

“Now faith is the substance of things hoped for; as it was the substance of things which have come to pass…” so reads the Lamsa translation from the Aramaic of Hebrews 11:1. The additional line in that phrase, “the substance of things which have come to pass” seems to point to experience again being the guiding force. If things in the past have come to be in substance, we can believe in the hope we have. 

If what we hope for has no substance in our experiences, we may need to relook at that hope and see if we are standing at a wall rather than dancing on the pin.

10 thoughts on “Dancing on the Head of a Pin

  1. I don’t know very many people that don’t want to “hope” for something, or have faith in something.

    God has made that apart of my spirit. If i can’t hope for anything or have faith that God is moving in my life, I would not be able to get a vision, or have dreams about fulfilling my destiny.

    I love to live in the moment, but I also love to dream.

    Children are the best at that! They hope all day for things to happen they usually get there way, and there is a reason why they do . Lots of hope and lots of faith. We should all be just like them!

  2. i used to say there are only 2 prayers that aren’t vain. i’m sorry and thank you. then someone told me the third, what are the marching orders. hope is that prayer. hope is the lynch pin for moving forward. it keeps us in the game. knowledge is useful to interpret our efforts, but as einstein said, imagination is more important than knowledge. i hope we all live happily ever after

  3. “the balance point”…yes, I believe that is the question.
    For me, the difference between letting go and giving in is the motive. What is it I truly want to happen? And why?

    And perhaps, then the turning point of dancing vs. standing at a wall is who’s leading whom?
    If I consciously choose to let go and let God be god, then I am dancing with God’s Spirit and for sure, God is leading.

    I’ve never been very good at dancing with my sisters. I’m never sure who’s “supposed” to lead.

  4. In buddhism, we are instructed to let go of both fear and hope, for the very reasons you’ve outlined. Hope by its very nature of wanting things to be different takes us away from being fully present with this moment. The paradox is that by accepting the present moment without judgment, we “wake up” to the best part of living.

    1. Interesting reply. Thanks. I wonder if letting go of both hope and fear is as possible as being in the present moment. In other words, hope and fear are human emotions and emotions are neither bad or good; the question lies in what we do with them. Releasing the attachment to hope or fear seems the task.

I love conversations! Let's start one.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s